Is Our Experience Causal or Symbolic? Personal or Archetypal? Inherited or Chosen?

Human experience sits at the crossroads of three languages: the psychological, the mythic, and the spiritual. Each tries to explain why things happen the way they do—why certain patterns repeat, why particular people and wounds find us. Yet none of these languages is complete on its own. Together they form a single multidimensional map of how consciousness grows through life.

1. The Psychological / Causal Lens
At this level, life is a chain of cause and effect.
Family dynamics, attachment styles, trauma, and nervous-system conditioning shape who we become.
The psyche is seen as a complex organism that learns through experience: safety wires calm, neglect wires vigilance, love wires trust.

This is the language of therapy, neuroscience, and behaviour.
Its tools are observation, regulation, and re-patterning.
When we feel anxious or reactive, this lens helps us track what triggered us and how to return to equilibrium.
It grounds the abstract in the tangible—the body, the lived history, the here-and-now.

2. The Archetypal / Mythic Lens
Step back and the same events reveal a larger drama.
Patterns of mother and child, betrayal and rebirth, exile and return, play out across generations.
The mythic lens asks not “What caused this?” but “What story is this expressing through me?”

Through this view, personal suffering becomes initiation.
We begin to see how our lives echo ancient motifs—the Devouring Mother, the Wounded Healer, the Trickster, the Phoenix.
The tools here are symbol, story, ritual, and imagination.
They don’t replace therapy; they give meaning to what therapy uncovers.

3. The Spiritual / Astrological Lens
The spiritual view holds that consciousness isn’t random; it unfolds through a pattern, a kind of cosmic curriculum.
Astrology is one language for that pattern.
It describes how different energies—elemental, planetary, archetypal—interweave in an individual life, suggesting what kinds of experiences will call a person to evolve.

In practice, astrology integrates the other two levels:
it speaks psychologically (temperament, drives, needs), mythically (archetypes and gods), and spiritually (of the evolution of consciousness).
Where the psyche sees trauma and the myth sees story, astrology provides the framework of timing and context—why certain lessons arise now, and how they fit into a longer arc.

In practice, astrology integrates the other two levels:
it speaks psychologically (temperament, drives, needs), mythically (archetypes and gods), and spiritually (of the evolution of consciousness).

4. The False Choice Between Levels
Modern thinking often insists we must pick one explanation:
• “It’s just childhood conditioning.”
• “It’s karmic destiny.”
• “It’s the family myth playing out.”

But reality isn’t that linear.
Each level describes the same field of experience viewed from a different altitude.
An event can be simultaneously causal, symbolic, inherited, and chosen—because life itself is multidimensional.

Just as our moods and elemental balances shift—fire one day, water the next—the level of reality that’s “lit up” also shifts.
Sometimes we’re dealing with the body and the nervous system; sometimes with ancestral stories; sometimes with the spirit’s geometry.
Whichever layer is most active is the one that needs attention at that moment.

 

5. Working With the Right Lens at the Right Time
| When you feel dysregulated or unsafe | → Ground in the physical and psychological: breath, body, boundaries, therapy. |
| When you feel lost or meaningless | → Move to the mythic: story, art, archetype, symbol. |
| When you sense larger patterns or timing | → Consult the spiritual / astrological: cycles, purpose, evolution. |

Each lens offers its own medicine; switching among them keeps the system whole.

Sometimes we’re dealing with the body and the nervous system; sometimes with ancestral stories; sometimes with the spirit’s geometry.
Whichever layer is most active is the one that needs attention at that moment.

6. A Unified View
The apparent contradiction between cause and meaning dissolves when we see them as layers of one reality.
Causality describes how energy moves; symbolism describes why it moves the way it does.
Inheritance shows where it came from; choice shows what consciousness does with it.

Astrology—understood not as prediction, but as a symbolic cosmology of all-encompassing consciousness itself—can function as the integrating backbone of this triad.
It already speaks the languages of psychology (inner patterns), myth (archetypal story), and spirit (evolutionary purpose).
Used this way, it doesn’t compete with therapy or mythic understanding; it weaves them together into one coherent display of a person’s unfolding path.

 

7. Living the Synthesis
Perhaps we don’t need to decide whether our experiences are caused or chosen, personal or collective.
They are all of these—threads in one web of becoming.

Our task is to sense which layer is vibrating now and meet it with the tools suited to its level.
When we can move fluidly among body, story, and spirit, life stops being a puzzle to solve and becomes an ecosystem to inhabit.